Taiwan is witnessing a heated debate on caning criminals after KMT legislator Hung Meng-kai proposed the controversial measure. Hung suggested that individuals convicted of fraud should face caning, citing Singapore’s expanded use of corporal punishment.
Hung highlighted that Singapore plans to administer up to 12 strokes to scam mules and up to 24 strokes to syndicate leaders. He asked, “Singapore can. Can Taiwan?” sparking public discussion online. His post received over 100,000 likes and 24,000 comments, with many supporting similar punishments for other crimes.
He argued that Taiwan has struggled to curb crimes such as fraud and drunk driving, despite increasing penalties. Hung proposed legislative exchanges with Singapore to study the system firsthand, referencing his recent visit to Japan with Legislative Speaker Han Kuo-yu.
However, the proposal has faced criticism. DPP legislator Chuang Jui-hsiung called it a “step backwards” for human rights. Chuang argued that corporal punishment could draw international condemnation and lacks rehabilitative value. He recommended stricter penalties and limiting parole for fraudsters instead.
Influencers and public figures have weighed in. Cheng Tsai-wei noted that Singapore maintains its caning system due to its unique economic position and insulation from international pressure. He cautioned that Taiwan’s obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights prevent corporal punishment.
Judicial caning in Singapore covers over 30 offenses, including robbery, drug trafficking, and vandalism. Only males aged 18 to 50 are eligible, receiving up to 24 strokes on the buttocks using a rattan cane.
Despite sparking debate, Hung did not confirm whether he would pursue legislation to introduce caning criminals into Taiwan’s legal system. The discussion highlights broader questions about deterrence, human rights, and international perception.
Observers note that the proposal may influence future debates on crime prevention while testing public tolerance for corporal punishment.
